After a few years of success in their original Oakville location (including being featured on the Canadian photocopy of Diners, Drive-ins and Dives, You Gotta Eat Here), Stoney’s Bread Company is expanding. I’ve been to the original location a few times and quite enjoyed it, so I was obviously pretty happy to hear they were coming a bit closer to home.
I didn’t even realize they had a burger. I went because I wanted to check out the new location, but then I saw the hamburger on the menu and it was game over. Do I want a burger? Yes. The answer to that question is always yes.
The burger is not-so-descriptively described on the menu as a “house made 6 oz. premium beef burger.” I guess the toppings aren’t set in stone.
The version I got, at least, is definitely a kitchen sink burger. Between the generous pile of sweet caramelized onions, the salty bacon, the sharp cheddar cheese, and all the other toppings (lettuce, pickles, and some kind of mayo I think), there’s a lot going on here. It’s a bit of a mess. A tasty mess, but a mess regardless.
Sadly, it’s not the beefiest tasting burger ever. In fact, I’d say there’s pretty much zero beefy flavour here, though this is the type of burger that’s so voluminously topped that the patty itself is almost just a vehicle for the toppings. It’s also a meatloaf burger, with stuff mixed into the patty — but again, the hamburger is so topping-heavy that it barely makes a difference either way.
But yes, it is tasty. I’ve had kitchen sink burgers where the toppings seem willy-nilly and the flavours never really cohere in any meaningful way, but here it all works: the saltiness of the cheddar and bacon is offset by the sweetness of the onions, and the richness of it all is cut by vinegary bite of the pickles.
The patty is almost an afterthought in this medley of flavours, but it’s substantial enough that it isn’t entirely drowned out. it is, however, a bit on the mushy side (a frequent issue with meatloaf burgers), but thankfully this isn’t nearly as egregious as it can sometimes be. It’s also a bit too finely ground, but the texture of the patty is otherwise mostly where it should be, with a decent amount of juiciness despite being cooked to well done.
The bun was okay; it was substantial enough to (mostly) hold up to the extremely messy burger, but it was untoasted and cold. Not room temperature; cold, like it had been kept in the fridge. That was a bit unpleasant, but the rest of the burger quickly warmed it up.
I will say that unless you’re seriously in the mood for a burger, it’s not what I’d order here. I’ve also had a couple of the sandwiches and the pizzas, and though I liked the burger, it was the weakest thing I’ve tried. The slow-roasted lamb sandwich in particular was quite delicious.
The burger comes with a side of baked potato wedges, and some kind of spicy mayo to dip them in. They were fine: well cooked, but nothing to write home about.